Quantcast

Florida Court Prohibits Evidence of Previous Domestic Violence in Rape Case Against Boyfriend – Harden v. State

It is a basic premise of Florida criminal law that a defendant can only be tried on the crimes for which he or she is charged. But what about using a defendant’s previous crimes or other “bad acts” in order to prove that he or she also committed the crime now charged? As Florida’s Fourth District Court of Appeal explains in Harden v. State, it depends.

Appellant Larry Harden was accused of beating and raping his then-girlfriend, K.W. after an argument in which Harden accused K.W. of having a relationship with another man. Prior to trial, the state prosecutor assigned to the case indicated that he intended to call K.W. as a witness and to ask her, among other things, about a previous domestic violence incident allegedly perpetrated by Harden six months prior to the incident at issue in the case. Despite Harden’s objection, the trial court ruled that the evidence was admissible as probative of his motive and intent. Following trial, Harden was convicted of sexual battery, false imprisonment and domestic battery.

On appeal, the Fourth District found that the trial court abused its discretion in permitting K.W. to testify about the alleged prior domestic violence incident. The general rule that any evidence that is relevant to proving a fact at issue in a case is admissible comes with some important exceptions, the court explained. Under Section 90.403, Florida Statutes (2011), for example, evidence “is inadmissible if its probative value is substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice, confusion of issues, misleading the jury or needless presentation of cumulative evidence.”

Citing Section 90.404(2)(a), the court further explained that fact evidence about a defendant having committed a similar crime as the one with which he or she is currently charged is admissible when relevant to prove a material fact in issue: proof of motive, opportunity, intent, preparation, plan, etc. The evidence is not admissible, however, where it is relevant solely to prove bad character or propensity.” This, according to the court, holds true even if the “prior bad act” is based on different factual circumstances than the acts at question in the present case.

In this case, “the earlier incident of domestic violence did nothing more than demonstrate appellant’s propensity for violence against his girlfriend,” the court ruled. According to the court, the primary issue at trial was whether K.W. consented to having sex with Harden on the night that she claims he raped her. Thus, Harden’s motive and intent were not in question. To the extent that the evidence was relevant in explaining why K.W. was slow to report the incident to the police, the court found that its value was outweighed by the potential unfair prejudice it could create: leading the jury to believe that because Harden allegedly committed domestic violence against K.W. in the past, he was likely to have committed the rape.

As a result, the court reversed Harden’s conviction and remanded the case for a new trial.

In Florida, domestic violence means any assault, battery, sexual assault, sexual battery, stalking, kidnapping, false imprisonment or any criminal offense resulting in physical injury or death of a person by a family or household member. The South Florida criminal defense attorneys at Anidjar & Levine are experienced at handling a variety of criminal matters, including those involving domestic violence. We are committed to helping you achieve the best results possible.

By Anidjar & Levine, P.A.

Leave a Reply

*

PKMN Company Store

Print Killer Store

Sponsors

InstaBabe of the Day!

Today's InstaBabe of the Day is Amanda Vex!!!!!! If you want to be considered for InstaBabe of the day, follow PrintKiller on Instagram!
  • @dplyusnin #repost ❤️
    4 hours ago by amandavex @dplyusnin #repost ❤️
  • @austinlindsay ☺️
    20 hours ago by amandavex @austinlindsay ☺️
  • Ideal. Can I relocate already? #perfect #serenity #getmeoutofvegas
    22 hours ago by amandavex Ideal. Can I relocate already? #perfect #serenity #getmeoutofvegas
  • #kittyeyes #wingedeyeliner
    2 days ago by amandavex #kittyeyes #wingedeyeliner
  • #latex 
Photos by amazing @radiant_inc @radiant_inc @radiant_inc
    3 days ago by amandavex #latex Photos by amazing @radiant_inc @radiant_inc @radiant_inc
  • @moarsound  Futurebabydaddy.
    4 days ago by amandavex @moarsound Futurebabydaddy.
  • #baby
    4 days ago by amandavex #baby
  • #Chi cleans for #hideki. ❤️❤️❤️❤️ #dressup #maid #onlymybfcanseethebackofthis #chobits #anime #manga #kitty #aries #excusethedjwires
    4 days ago by amandavex #Chi cleans for #hideki. ❤️❤️❤️❤️ #dressup #maid #onlymybfcanseethebackofthis #chobits #anime #manga #kitty #aries #excusethedjwires
  • My idea of Perfection. #starcluster #astronomy #outterspace #incomparable #beauty
    6 days ago by amandavex My idea of Perfection. #starcluster #astronomy #outterspace #incomparable #beauty
  • Juicy.
    6 days ago by amandavex Juicy.
  • Thank you @grams_best  for the shout out. Go follow them for beautiful girls! @grams_best @grams_best
    7 days ago by amandavex Thank you @grams_best for the shout out. Go follow them for beautiful girls! @grams_best @grams_best
  • Lazy dayss
    7 days ago by amandavex Lazy dayss
  • #blackandwhite
    1 week ago by amandavex #blackandwhite
  • Chapstick + mascara.
    1 week ago by amandavex Chapstick + mascara.

Instagramer of the Day!

Today's Instagramer of the Day is Rolling Paper Depot!!! If you want to be considered for Instagramer of the day, follow PrintKiller on Instagram!
  • Found this dude on the #subway in #NYC. ?  The Cure shirt & pink knitting. Bet he's rockin' some good ol' #deathmetal in those phones too. ? He doesn't know it yet, but we're already #bestbuds. ?
    5 hours ago by RollingPaperDepot Found this dude on the #subway in #NYC. ? The Cure shirt & pink knitting. Bet he's rockin' some good ol' #deathmetal in those phones too. ? He doesn't know it yet, but we're already #bestbuds. ?
  • ENDS TOMORROW!!
**Add your favorite #Wiz lyrics for an extra entry**
☁Repost this photo and tag #wizrpd for a chance to win some wiz khalifa papers and a tray!
☁Must be 18 or older and following @rollingpaperdepot and @stay_green !
☁Unlimited ammount of entries!! Tag @rawlife247 and @mistercap!
☁Giveaway ends next friday the 2nd!
☁Good luck!

#staygreen #rollingpaperdepot #giveaway #cheers #dank #green #love #smoke #high #joints #rawlife247 #wedemboyz #TGOD #taylorgang #blacchollywood #Wiz #play #win #fun #games #contest #giveaway #winning
    8 hours ago by RollingPaperDepot ENDS TOMORROW!! **Add your favorite #Wiz lyrics for an extra entry** ☁Repost this photo and tag #wizrpd for a chance to win some wiz khalifa papers and a tray! ☁Must be 18 or older and following @rollingpaperdepot and @stay_green ! ☁Unlimited ammount of entries!! Tag @rawlife247 and @mistercap! ☁Giveaway ends next friday the 2nd! ☁Good luck! #staygreen #rollingpaperdepot #giveaway #cheers #dank #green #love #smoke #high #joints #rawlife247 #wedemboyz #TGOD #taylorgang #blacchollywood #Wiz #play #win #fun #games #contest #giveaway #winning
  • #highdeas ?
    21 hours ago by RollingPaperDepot #highdeas ?
  • @inked_out_gondhi ➕ @mistercap ➡ #rawlife
    1 day ago by RollingPaperDepot @inked_out_gondhi ➕ @mistercap ➡ #rawlife
  • Wake up, Bake up. Would you smoke with @ganjagypsy? #wcw #stonerbabes
    1 day ago by RollingPaperDepot Wake up, Bake up. Would you smoke with @ganjagypsy? #wcw #stonerbabes
  • I see fire. ?rollingpaperdepot.com/Metal-Palms-Clipper-Lighter
?rollingpaperdepot.com/Metal-8-Ball-Clipper-Lighter
    2 days ago by RollingPaperDepot I see fire. ?rollingpaperdepot.com/Metal-Palms-Clipper-Lighter ?rollingpaperdepot.com/Metal-8-Ball-Clipper-Lighter
  • Rise & Shine! ? (Image via @rawlife247)
    2 days ago by RollingPaperDepot Rise & Shine! ? (Image via @rawlife247)
  • GIVE AWAY TIME!! **Add your favorite #Wiz lyrics for an extra entry**
☁Repost this photo and tag #wizrpd for a chance to win some wiz khalifa papers and a tray!
☁Must be 18 or older and following @rollingpaperdepot and @stay_green !
☁Unlimited ammount of entries!! Tag @rawlife247 and @mistercap!
☁Giveaway ends next friday the 2nd!
☁Good luck!

#staygreen #rollingpaperdepot #giveaway #cheers #dank #green #love #smoke #high #joints #rawlife247 #wedemboyz
    3 days ago by RollingPaperDepot GIVE AWAY TIME!! **Add your favorite #Wiz lyrics for an extra entry** ☁Repost this photo and tag #wizrpd for a chance to win some wiz khalifa papers and a tray! ☁Must be 18 or older and following @rollingpaperdepot and @stay_green ! ☁Unlimited ammount of entries!! Tag @rawlife247 and @mistercap! ☁Giveaway ends next friday the 2nd! ☁Good luck! #staygreen #rollingpaperdepot #giveaway #cheers #dank #green #love #smoke #high #joints #rawlife247 #wedemboyz
  • Time for a #ScoobySnack!
    3 days ago by RollingPaperDepot Time for a #ScoobySnack!
  • ??
    3 days ago by RollingPaperDepot ??
  • iBlaze Soy/Terpene Candles now in stock!
?7 flavors ?long-lasting ?did I mention #terpene⁉

Use code INSTASMOKE ? RollingPaperDepot.com/Ivanna-Blaze-Soy-Terpene-Candle ↔ $9.99

Comment Flavor, Quantity, & PayPal address to buy now!
    3 days ago by RollingPaperDepot iBlaze Soy/Terpene Candles now in stock! ?7 flavors ?long-lasting ?did I mention #terpene⁉ Use code INSTASMOKE ? RollingPaperDepot.com/Ivanna-Blaze-Soy-Terpene-Candle ↔ $9.99 Comment Flavor, Quantity, & PayPal address to buy now!
  • Idk why yesterday was the best day ever do @yesjulz, be we're lovin' this snap! ??
    3 days ago by RollingPaperDepot Idk why yesterday was the best day ever do @yesjulz, be we're lovin' this snap! ??
  • rollingpaperdepot.com/Raw-Super-Shredder

Only ✌? 25 in stock.  Get them  before @RAWLIFE247 posts them & they are all gone❗
    4 days ago by RollingPaperDepot rollingpaperdepot.com/Raw-Super-Shredder Only ✌? 25 in stock. Get them before @RAWLIFE247 posts them & they are all gone❗
  • Good morning. ? ? by @tokerz_420
    4 days ago by RollingPaperDepot Good morning. ? ? by @tokerz_420
  • #psa #themoreyouknow
    5 days ago by RollingPaperDepot #psa #themoreyouknow

InstaLame of the Day!

Today's InstaLame of the Day is PDQ - If Your Going to Come to Fort Lauderdale to Sell Chicken Tenders, Then They Need to at Least be Better Than Publix's! Yours Aren't Even close!!! Also Who Wants a Half Full Little Cardboard Box of Fries, When Five Guys Gives You a Full Brown Bag Across the Street!!! !!! If you know someone who is InstaLame tag us in their comments @PrintKiller on Instagram!
  • Taste what everyone is talking about! Happy #NationalChickenTendersDay!
    4 days ago by pdqfreshfood Taste what everyone is talking about! Happy #NationalChickenTendersDay!
  • It tastes just like the real thing. Come and get it before it's gone! #PDQ
    6 days ago by pdqfreshfood It tastes just like the real thing. Come and get it before it's gone! #PDQ
  • Hey foodies, share your #PDQFreshFood photos for a chance to be featured in our stores!
    1 week ago by pdqfreshfood Hey foodies, share your #PDQFreshFood photos for a chance to be featured in our stores!
  • 10 days left of #YearofFresh! You still have time to enter to win #PDQ for a year! EatPDQ.com/YearofFresh
    1 week ago by pdqfreshfood 10 days left of #YearofFresh! You still have time to enter to win #PDQ for a year! EatPDQ.com/YearofFresh
  • Long drive today? Make a pit stop, the crispy turkey sandwich is waiting for you. ‪#‎PDQ‬
    2 weeks ago by pdqfreshfood Long drive today? Make a pit stop, the crispy turkey sandwich is waiting for you. ‪#‎PDQ‬
  • Rocking #PDQ sunglasses on #NationalSunglassesDay! #tbt
    2 weeks ago by pdqfreshfood Rocking #PDQ sunglasses on #NationalSunglassesDay! #tbt
  • Lunch Break! #PDQ
    2 weeks ago by pdqfreshfood Lunch Break! #PDQ
  • Lots of chickens here at our Grand Opening on Waters Avenue in Tampa today. The fun continues until 10 pm tonight.
    3 weeks ago by pdqfreshfood Lots of chickens here at our Grand Opening on Waters Avenue in Tampa today. The fun continues until 10 pm tonight.
  • No, you're not dreaming! Visit www.eatpdq.com/YearofFresh today for your chance to win PDQ for a Year! #YearofFresh #PDQ
    3 weeks ago by pdqfreshfood No, you're not dreaming! Visit www.eatpdq.com/YearofFresh today for your chance to win PDQ for a Year! #YearofFresh #PDQ
  • BOGO Tenders July 4-6! #PDQ #BOGO #4thofJuly
    4 weeks ago by pdqfreshfood BOGO Tenders July 4-6! #PDQ #BOGO #4thofJuly
  • Fresh Tenders and fireworks! Perfect combination. Get BOGO Tenders July 4-6! #PDQ #4thofJuly
    1 month ago by pdqfreshfood Fresh Tenders and fireworks! Perfect combination. Get BOGO Tenders July 4-6! #PDQ #4thofJuly
  • Our Team Members have on their #PDQ shades for #NationalSunglassesDay. Show us your wackiest pair and receive half off all day!
    1 month ago by pdqfreshfood Our Team Members have on their #PDQ shades for #NationalSunglassesDay. Show us your wackiest pair and receive half off all day!
  • You still have time to find your wackiest sunglasses and receive half off any item tomorrow! We can't decide! #NationalSunglassesDay #PDQ
    1 month ago by pdqfreshfood You still have time to find your wackiest sunglasses and receive half off any item tomorrow! We can't decide! #NationalSunglassesDay #PDQ
  • USA! USA! #USMNT #1N1T #PDQ
    1 month ago by pdqfreshfood USA! USA! #USMNT #1N1T #PDQ
  • This Friday is #NationalSunglassesDay! Wear your wackiest pair to any location and get 50% off! #PDQ
    1 month ago by pdqfreshfood This Friday is #NationalSunglassesDay! Wear your wackiest pair to any location and get 50% off! #PDQ

Sponsors

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers