Quantcast

Is The Individual Mandate Constitutional?

The main question before the Supreme Court in terms of the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) is whether the federal government has the power to mandate that American citizens purchase a product or service offered by a private company. This question needs some explanation. Part of the separation of powers in our governmental design is the concept of federalism. One aspect of federalism is the balance concerning what powers the state governments have over its citizens and the power that the federal government also has over citizens. The states may be able to have an individual mandate to buy health insurance, but the federal government may not have that power. It has been accepted that individual states can order citizens to purchase health insurance as seen in Romneycare in Massachusetts. The question before the court is whether the federal government can order every American to purchase health insurance.

Some have wrongly compared this to the requirement for all Americans to be part of social security or medicare. These programs are based on the power of the federal government to tax, which is established as constitutional. Another difference between those programs and the private insurance mandate is that social security and medicare are both administered by the federal government and are not private products or services. That the federal government has the power to pass laws that cause people to be taxed and can administer those programs has been established. The question before the Supreme Court is whether the federal government can require citizens to purchase a private product or service. Interestingly enough, had Congress passed and the president signed a program that taxed people for a new government-run, single-payer system, the constitutionality of that would probably not be in question. The new national health program would have been based on the power of the federal government to tax and administer the program. This would have passed constitutional muster and would have been seen as being similar to social security and medicare. The majority in Congress, along with President Obama, chose to require individuals to purchase insurance from private companies and this created the issue of whether the individual mandate is constitutional. Whether the federal government has the authority to require each person to purchase a private product and service is what makes it a constitutional question.

Some have also wrongly compared this is to the mandates to purchase auto insurance coverage. One difference is that auto insurance is done on a state level and not a federal level. Driving is a privilege and not a right, so each state can have requirements that extend to those who wish to own automobiles due to the inherent possibilities of injury to oneself or to others. Additionally, if one chooses not to own an automobile, there is no requirement to have insurance, which is unlike the federal requirement for all Americans to have health insurance. If this is found to be constitutional, then theoretically, the federal government could require all its citizens to purchase all sorts of products like cell phones, computers, bicycles, and internet service.

Leave a Reply

*

PKMN Company Store

Print Killer Store

Sponsors

InstaBabe of the Day!

Today's InstaBabe of the Day is Andi Phillips!!!!!! If you want to be considered for InstaBabe of the day, follow PrintKiller on Instagram!
  • Rule #1 never be #2 ? photo cred @ajdayphoto
    1 day ago by andiphillipsxo Rule #1 never be #2 ? photo cred @ajdayphoto
  • Sometimes good things fall apart so better things can fall together ❤️ photo cred @ajdayphoto
    1 day ago by andiphillipsxo Sometimes good things fall apart so better things can fall together ❤️ photo cred @ajdayphoto
  • Elegance is the only beauty that never fades ? #audreyhepburn photo cred @ajdayphoto
    2 days ago by andiphillipsxo Elegance is the only beauty that never fades ? #audreyhepburn photo cred @ajdayphoto
  • Excited to start this season as co captain with these talented ladies thanks to @donnilala and another thanks to @fitdesiree for choreographing yet another master piece ❤️ I can't wait to perform it @atlhawkscheer #ahc #atlanta #lovemyteam #atlantahawkscheerleaders #bestcoach #desir80s
    3 days ago by andiphillipsxo Excited to start this season as co captain with these talented ladies thanks to @donnilala and another thanks to @fitdesiree for choreographing yet another master piece ❤️ I can't wait to perform it @atlhawkscheer #ahc #atlanta #lovemyteam #atlantahawkscheerleaders #bestcoach #desir80s
  • Saturday shenanigans ? #atlanta  #funtimes
    4 days ago by andiphillipsxo Saturday shenanigans ? #atlanta #funtimes
  • Day 5 and cheer camp has come to an end ? #bittersweet #ahc #3rdgrade #cheercamp #ilovemyjob @atlhawkscheer
    6 days ago by andiphillipsxo Day 5 and cheer camp has come to an end ? #bittersweet #ahc #3rdgrade #cheercamp #ilovemyjob @atlhawkscheer
  • Little Sally walkin for swim time at cheer camp with my little monkeys ? #ilovemyjob #ahc #cheercamp @atlhawkscheer
    7 days ago by andiphillipsxo Little Sally walkin for swim time at cheer camp with my little monkeys ? #ilovemyjob #ahc #cheercamp @atlhawkscheer
  • Day 3 of cheer camp with our itty bitties ? #girlfriends #snap #shhhh #ilovemyjob #ahc #cheercamp @atlhawkscheer
    1 week ago by andiphillipsxo Day 3 of cheer camp with our itty bitties ? #girlfriends #snap #shhhh #ilovemyjob #ahc #cheercamp @atlhawkscheer
  • Day 2 of cheer camp today and these little divas drew pictures for me and of me ❤️ #3rdgrade #cheercamp #ilovemyjob @atlhawkscheer
    1 week ago by andiphillipsxo Day 2 of cheer camp today and these little divas drew pictures for me and of me ❤️ #3rdgrade #cheercamp #ilovemyjob @atlhawkscheer
  • Day 1 of cheer camp was a success ? @atlhawkscheer #3rdgrade #cheercamp
    1 week ago by andiphillipsxo Day 1 of cheer camp was a success ? @atlhawkscheer #3rdgrade #cheercamp
  • Who will be today's summer league star? Find out at 6:30pm on nba.com @atlhawks #gohawks #atlhawks #atlants #ahc
    2 weeks ago by andiphillipsxo Who will be today's summer league star? Find out at 6:30pm on nba.com @atlhawks #gohawks #atlhawks #atlants #ahc
  • That they do ? #hairflip #quotes
    2 weeks ago by andiphillipsxo That they do ? #hairflip #quotes
  • I'm a little drunk on you and high on summertime ??☀️ #favoritetimeoftheyear #sunkissed #georgia #southernbelle #bikini photo cred @genoeugenehowardphotography
    2 weeks ago by andiphillipsxo I'm a little drunk on you and high on summertime ??☀️ #favoritetimeoftheyear #sunkissed #georgia #southernbelle #bikini photo cred @genoeugenehowardphotography
  • Kermit sips tea ☕️ #nba #bandwagon
    2 weeks ago by andiphillipsxo Kermit sips tea ☕️ #nba #bandwagon
  • Suns out, guns out ☀️ #bikini #georgia #fitgirls #healthy #fitness
    2 weeks ago by andiphillipsxo Suns out, guns out ☀️ #bikini #georgia #fitgirls #healthy #fitness

Instagramer of the Day!

Today's Instagramer of the Day is Rip Curl USA!!! If you want to be considered for Instagramer of the day, follow PrintKiller on Instagram!
  • @kekoabacalso last week in blacks beach CA!
    12 months ago by ripcurlusa @kekoabacalso last week in blacks beach CA!
  • LOOK DEEPER. #livethesearch
    12 months ago by ripcurlusa LOOK DEEPER. #livethesearch
  • @bhollyb 4days ago for #kushcush photo shoot
    12 months ago by ripcurlusa @bhollyb 4days ago for #kushcush photo shoot
  • @bhollyb 2 years ago, #waybackwednesday #hang10
    12 months ago by ripcurlusa @bhollyb 2 years ago, #waybackwednesday #hang10

InstaLame of the Day!

Today's InstaLame of the Day is Scott for Florida - Governor Rick Scott Got Us Nationally Embarrassed Again. This Time On John Oliver's Show Last Week Tonight. See The Clip In The Print Killer News Feed!!! !!! If you know someone who is InstaLame tag us in their comments @PrintKiller on Instagram!
  • How adorable is Sebastian in his sunglasses?
    1 day ago by scottforflorida How adorable is Sebastian in his sunglasses?
  • This little cutie loves Rick Scott!
    2 days ago by scottforflorida This little cutie loves Rick Scott!
  • Grateful for every volunteer! #letskeepworking
    6 days ago by scottforflorida Grateful for every volunteer! #letskeepworking
  • Throwback Thursday: I love my beautiful wife. –RS #tbt
    1 week ago by scottforflorida Throwback Thursday: I love my beautiful wife. –RS #tbt
  • It's always a privilege to honor America's heroes.
    1 week ago by scottforflorida It's always a privilege to honor America's heroes.
  • Met some wonderful supporters yesterday at La Pequena Columbia in Tampa.
    1 week ago by scottforflorida Met some wonderful supporters yesterday at La Pequena Columbia in Tampa.
  • What a great weekend spending time with Ann and Auguste. He’s growing up fast! -RS
    1 week ago by scottforflorida What a great weekend spending time with Ann and Auguste. He’s growing up fast! -RS
  • Volunteer #selfie! #letskeepworking
    2 weeks ago by scottforflorida Volunteer #selfie! #letskeepworking
  • Throwback Thursday: Auguste and Quinton are growing up so fast! #tbt
    2 weeks ago by scottforflorida Throwback Thursday: Auguste and Quinton are growing up so fast! #tbt
  • Ribbon cutting time at The Villages this past Friday for Gov. Scott’s Lake Sumter Landing office.
    2 weeks ago by scottforflorida Ribbon cutting time at The Villages this past Friday for Gov. Scott’s Lake Sumter Landing office.
  • Gov. Scott joined our volunteers at The Villages to make some calls to Florida voters! #sayfie
    2 weeks ago by scottforflorida Gov. Scott joined our volunteers at The Villages to make some calls to Florida voters! #sayfie
  • It was a pleasure to meet Dale Earnhardt Jr. and all the other drivers and crew members at the #CokeZero400. #sayfie
    2 weeks ago by scottforflorida It was a pleasure to meet Dale Earnhardt Jr. and all the other drivers and crew members at the #CokeZero400. #sayfie
  • We have the best volunteers! Thank you all for your dedication and hard work. #letskeepworking #sayfie
    3 weeks ago by scottforflorida We have the best volunteers! Thank you all for your dedication and hard work. #letskeepworking #sayfie
  • Throwback Thursday: Can you spot Governor Scott? #tbt #navy #sayfie
    3 weeks ago by scottforflorida Throwback Thursday: Can you spot Governor Scott? #tbt #navy #sayfie
  • Throwback to all the great days in June. #tbt#sayfie
    3 weeks ago by scottforflorida Throwback to all the great days in June. #tbt#sayfie

Sponsors

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers