Quantcast

Is The Individual Mandate Constitutional?

The main question before the Supreme Court in terms of the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) is whether the federal government has the power to mandate that American citizens purchase a product or service offered by a private company. This question needs some explanation. Part of the separation of powers in our governmental design is the concept of federalism. One aspect of federalism is the balance concerning what powers the state governments have over its citizens and the power that the federal government also has over citizens. The states may be able to have an individual mandate to buy health insurance, but the federal government may not have that power. It has been accepted that individual states can order citizens to purchase health insurance as seen in Romneycare in Massachusetts. The question before the court is whether the federal government can order every American to purchase health insurance.

Some have wrongly compared this to the requirement for all Americans to be part of social security or medicare. These programs are based on the power of the federal government to tax, which is established as constitutional. Another difference between those programs and the private insurance mandate is that social security and medicare are both administered by the federal government and are not private products or services. That the federal government has the power to pass laws that cause people to be taxed and can administer those programs has been established. The question before the Supreme Court is whether the federal government can require citizens to purchase a private product or service. Interestingly enough, had Congress passed and the president signed a program that taxed people for a new government-run, single-payer system, the constitutionality of that would probably not be in question. The new national health program would have been based on the power of the federal government to tax and administer the program. This would have passed constitutional muster and would have been seen as being similar to social security and medicare. The majority in Congress, along with President Obama, chose to require individuals to purchase insurance from private companies and this created the issue of whether the individual mandate is constitutional. Whether the federal government has the authority to require each person to purchase a private product and service is what makes it a constitutional question.

Some have also wrongly compared this is to the mandates to purchase auto insurance coverage. One difference is that auto insurance is done on a state level and not a federal level. Driving is a privilege and not a right, so each state can have requirements that extend to those who wish to own automobiles due to the inherent possibilities of injury to oneself or to others. Additionally, if one chooses not to own an automobile, there is no requirement to have insurance, which is unlike the federal requirement for all Americans to have health insurance. If this is found to be constitutional, then theoretically, the federal government could require all its citizens to purchase all sorts of products like cell phones, computers, bicycles, and internet service.

Leave a Reply

*

PKMN Company Store

Print Killer Store

Sponsors

InstaBabe of the Day!

Today's InstaBabe of the Day is Amanda Vex!!!!!! If you want to be considered for InstaBabe of the day, follow PrintKiller on Instagram!
  • Last #repost , promise! ? tan and glowy. Favorite shot ever by the amazingly talented @dplyusnin  his every shot is absolute art.
    1 day ago by amandavex Last #repost , promise! ? tan and glowy. Favorite shot ever by the amazingly talented @dplyusnin his every shot is absolute art.
  • No one is perfect!
    1 day ago by amandavex No one is perfect!
  • @dplyusnin #repost ❤️
    1 day ago by amandavex @dplyusnin #repost ❤️
  • @austinlindsay ☺️
    2 days ago by amandavex @austinlindsay ☺️
  • Ideal. Can I relocate already? #perfect #serenity #getmeoutofvegas
    2 days ago by amandavex Ideal. Can I relocate already? #perfect #serenity #getmeoutofvegas
  • #kittyeyes #wingedeyeliner
    3 days ago by amandavex #kittyeyes #wingedeyeliner
  • #latex 
Photos by amazing @radiant_inc @radiant_inc @radiant_inc
    4 days ago by amandavex #latex Photos by amazing @radiant_inc @radiant_inc @radiant_inc
  • @moarsound  Futurebabydaddy.
    5 days ago by amandavex @moarsound Futurebabydaddy.
  • #baby
    5 days ago by amandavex #baby
  • #Chi cleans for #hideki. ❤️❤️❤️❤️ #dressup #maid #onlymybfcanseethebackofthis #chobits #anime #manga #kitty #aries #excusethedjwires
    5 days ago by amandavex #Chi cleans for #hideki. ❤️❤️❤️❤️ #dressup #maid #onlymybfcanseethebackofthis #chobits #anime #manga #kitty #aries #excusethedjwires
  • My idea of Perfection. #starcluster #astronomy #outterspace #incomparable #beauty
    1 week ago by amandavex My idea of Perfection. #starcluster #astronomy #outterspace #incomparable #beauty
  • Juicy.
    1 week ago by amandavex Juicy.
  • Thank you @grams_best  for the shout out. Go follow them for beautiful girls! @grams_best @grams_best
    1 week ago by amandavex Thank you @grams_best for the shout out. Go follow them for beautiful girls! @grams_best @grams_best
  • Lazy dayss
    1 week ago by amandavex Lazy dayss

Instagramer of the Day!

Today's Instagramer of the Day is Rolling Paper Depot!!! If you want to be considered for Instagramer of the day, follow PrintKiller on Instagram!
  • That e-lighter game poppin' off. ⚡️ Use code INSTASMOKE ? rollingpaperdepot.com/Zen-E-Lighter
    5 hours ago by RollingPaperDepot That e-lighter game poppin' off. ⚡️ Use code INSTASMOKE ? rollingpaperdepot.com/Zen-E-Lighter
  • #friedday #TGIF
    7 hours ago by RollingPaperDepot #friedday #TGIF
  • ENDS TODAY!!
**Add your favorite #Wiz lyrics for an extra entry**
☁Repost this photo and tag #wizrpd for a chance to win some wiz khalifa papers and a tray!
☁Must be 18 or older and following @rollingpaperdepot and @stay_green !
☁Unlimited ammount of entries!! Tag @rawlife247 and @mistercap!
☁Giveaway ends next friday the 1st!
☁Good luck!

#staygreen #rollingpaperdepot #giveaway #cheers #dank #green #love #smoke #high #joints #rawlife247 #wedemboyz #TGOD #taylorgang #blacchollywood #Wiz #play #win #fun #games #contest #giveaway #winning
    10 hours ago by RollingPaperDepot ENDS TODAY!! **Add your favorite #Wiz lyrics for an extra entry** ☁Repost this photo and tag #wizrpd for a chance to win some wiz khalifa papers and a tray! ☁Must be 18 or older and following @rollingpaperdepot and @stay_green ! ☁Unlimited ammount of entries!! Tag @rawlife247 and @mistercap! ☁Giveaway ends next friday the 1st! ☁Good luck! #staygreen #rollingpaperdepot #giveaway #cheers #dank #green #love #smoke #high #joints #rawlife247 #wedemboyz #TGOD #taylorgang #blacchollywood #Wiz #play #win #fun #games #contest #giveaway #winning
  • See the #s? VOTE for your favorite! Then see more at rollingpaperdepot.com/Awesome-T-Shirts
    13 hours ago by RollingPaperDepot See the #s? VOTE for your favorite! Then see more at rollingpaperdepot.com/Awesome-T-Shirts
  • YEAH!! ?
    22 hours ago by RollingPaperDepot YEAH!! ?
  • Now in SLIM! rollingpaperdepot.com/RAW-Unbleached-Cotton-Filters-200-Filters @rawlife247 #rawthentic #RAW #rawlife #rollyourown
    1 day ago by RollingPaperDepot Now in SLIM! rollingpaperdepot.com/RAW-Unbleached-Cotton-Filters-200-Filters @rawlife247 #rawthentic #RAW #rawlife #rollyourown
  • Found this dude on the #subway in #NYC. ?  The Cure shirt & pink knitting. Bet he's rockin' some good ol' #deathmetal in those phones too. ? He doesn't know it yet, but we're already #bestbuds. ?
    1 day ago by RollingPaperDepot Found this dude on the #subway in #NYC. ? The Cure shirt & pink knitting. Bet he's rockin' some good ol' #deathmetal in those phones too. ? He doesn't know it yet, but we're already #bestbuds. ?
  • ENDS TOMORROW!!
**Add your favorite #Wiz lyrics for an extra entry**
☁Repost this photo and tag #wizrpd for a chance to win some wiz khalifa papers and a tray!
☁Must be 18 or older and following @rollingpaperdepot and @stay_green !
☁Unlimited ammount of entries!! Tag @rawlife247 and @mistercap!
☁Giveaway ends next friday the 2nd!
☁Good luck!

#staygreen #rollingpaperdepot #giveaway #cheers #dank #green #love #smoke #high #joints #rawlife247 #wedemboyz #TGOD #taylorgang #blacchollywood #Wiz #play #win #fun #games #contest #giveaway #winning
    1 day ago by RollingPaperDepot ENDS TOMORROW!! **Add your favorite #Wiz lyrics for an extra entry** ☁Repost this photo and tag #wizrpd for a chance to win some wiz khalifa papers and a tray! ☁Must be 18 or older and following @rollingpaperdepot and @stay_green ! ☁Unlimited ammount of entries!! Tag @rawlife247 and @mistercap! ☁Giveaway ends next friday the 2nd! ☁Good luck! #staygreen #rollingpaperdepot #giveaway #cheers #dank #green #love #smoke #high #joints #rawlife247 #wedemboyz #TGOD #taylorgang #blacchollywood #Wiz #play #win #fun #games #contest #giveaway #winning
  • #highdeas ?
    2 days ago by RollingPaperDepot #highdeas ?
  • @inked_out_gondhi ➕ @mistercap ➡ #rawlife
    2 days ago by RollingPaperDepot @inked_out_gondhi ➕ @mistercap ➡ #rawlife
  • Wake up, Bake up. Would you smoke with @ganjagypsy? #wcw #stonerbabes
    2 days ago by RollingPaperDepot Wake up, Bake up. Would you smoke with @ganjagypsy? #wcw #stonerbabes
  • I see fire. ?rollingpaperdepot.com/Metal-Palms-Clipper-Lighter
?rollingpaperdepot.com/Metal-8-Ball-Clipper-Lighter
    3 days ago by RollingPaperDepot I see fire. ?rollingpaperdepot.com/Metal-Palms-Clipper-Lighter ?rollingpaperdepot.com/Metal-8-Ball-Clipper-Lighter
  • Rise & Shine! ? (Image via @rawlife247)
    3 days ago by RollingPaperDepot Rise & Shine! ? (Image via @rawlife247)
  • GIVE AWAY TIME!! **Add your favorite #Wiz lyrics for an extra entry**
☁Repost this photo and tag #wizrpd for a chance to win some wiz khalifa papers and a tray!
☁Must be 18 or older and following @rollingpaperdepot and @stay_green !
☁Unlimited ammount of entries!! Tag @rawlife247 and @mistercap!
☁Giveaway ends next friday the 2nd!
☁Good luck!

#staygreen #rollingpaperdepot #giveaway #cheers #dank #green #love #smoke #high #joints #rawlife247 #wedemboyz
    4 days ago by RollingPaperDepot GIVE AWAY TIME!! **Add your favorite #Wiz lyrics for an extra entry** ☁Repost this photo and tag #wizrpd for a chance to win some wiz khalifa papers and a tray! ☁Must be 18 or older and following @rollingpaperdepot and @stay_green ! ☁Unlimited ammount of entries!! Tag @rawlife247 and @mistercap! ☁Giveaway ends next friday the 2nd! ☁Good luck! #staygreen #rollingpaperdepot #giveaway #cheers #dank #green #love #smoke #high #joints #rawlife247 #wedemboyz
  • Time for a #ScoobySnack!
    4 days ago by RollingPaperDepot Time for a #ScoobySnack!

InstaLame of the Day!

Today's InstaLame of the Day is PDQ - If Your Going to Come to Fort Lauderdale to Sell Chicken Tenders, Then They Need to at Least be Better Than Publix's! Yours Aren't Even close!!! Also Who Wants a Half Full Little Cardboard Box of Fries, When Five Guys Gives You a Full Brown Bag Across the Street!!! !!! If you know someone who is InstaLame tag us in their comments @PrintKiller on Instagram!
  • Introducing our newest addition to the shake family. #PDQ
    11 hours ago by pdqfreshfood Introducing our newest addition to the shake family. #PDQ
  • Taste what everyone is talking about! Happy #NationalChickenTendersDay!
    6 days ago by pdqfreshfood Taste what everyone is talking about! Happy #NationalChickenTendersDay!
  • It tastes just like the real thing. Come and get it before it's gone! #PDQ
    1 week ago by pdqfreshfood It tastes just like the real thing. Come and get it before it's gone! #PDQ
  • Hey foodies, share your #PDQFreshFood photos for a chance to be featured in our stores!
    1 week ago by pdqfreshfood Hey foodies, share your #PDQFreshFood photos for a chance to be featured in our stores!
  • 10 days left of #YearofFresh! You still have time to enter to win #PDQ for a year! EatPDQ.com/YearofFresh
    2 weeks ago by pdqfreshfood 10 days left of #YearofFresh! You still have time to enter to win #PDQ for a year! EatPDQ.com/YearofFresh
  • Long drive today? Make a pit stop, the crispy turkey sandwich is waiting for you. ‪#‎PDQ‬
    2 weeks ago by pdqfreshfood Long drive today? Make a pit stop, the crispy turkey sandwich is waiting for you. ‪#‎PDQ‬
  • Rocking #PDQ sunglasses on #NationalSunglassesDay! #tbt
    2 weeks ago by pdqfreshfood Rocking #PDQ sunglasses on #NationalSunglassesDay! #tbt
  • Lunch Break! #PDQ
    3 weeks ago by pdqfreshfood Lunch Break! #PDQ
  • Lots of chickens here at our Grand Opening on Waters Avenue in Tampa today. The fun continues until 10 pm tonight.
    3 weeks ago by pdqfreshfood Lots of chickens here at our Grand Opening on Waters Avenue in Tampa today. The fun continues until 10 pm tonight.
  • No, you're not dreaming! Visit www.eatpdq.com/YearofFresh today for your chance to win PDQ for a Year! #YearofFresh #PDQ
    3 weeks ago by pdqfreshfood No, you're not dreaming! Visit www.eatpdq.com/YearofFresh today for your chance to win PDQ for a Year! #YearofFresh #PDQ
  • BOGO Tenders July 4-6! #PDQ #BOGO #4thofJuly
    4 weeks ago by pdqfreshfood BOGO Tenders July 4-6! #PDQ #BOGO #4thofJuly
  • Fresh Tenders and fireworks! Perfect combination. Get BOGO Tenders July 4-6! #PDQ #4thofJuly
    1 month ago by pdqfreshfood Fresh Tenders and fireworks! Perfect combination. Get BOGO Tenders July 4-6! #PDQ #4thofJuly
  • Our Team Members have on their #PDQ shades for #NationalSunglassesDay. Show us your wackiest pair and receive half off all day!
    1 month ago by pdqfreshfood Our Team Members have on their #PDQ shades for #NationalSunglassesDay. Show us your wackiest pair and receive half off all day!
  • You still have time to find your wackiest sunglasses and receive half off any item tomorrow! We can't decide! #NationalSunglassesDay #PDQ
    1 month ago by pdqfreshfood You still have time to find your wackiest sunglasses and receive half off any item tomorrow! We can't decide! #NationalSunglassesDay #PDQ
  • USA! USA! #USMNT #1N1T #PDQ
    1 month ago by pdqfreshfood USA! USA! #USMNT #1N1T #PDQ

Sponsors

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers